A tree is not just shade and fall color. To the rest of the neighborhood, the birds, the bees, the moths, the salamanders under the leaf litter, a tree is either a grocery store or a plastic replica of one, and the difference is almost entirely a matter of species.
The reason is simple. Insects are specialists. The caterpillar of a particular moth can eat oak leaves and nothing else, because its ancestors spent a few million years learning to detoxify oak chemistry. A tree that arrived from East Asia or Southern Europe in the last two centuries is a stranger to that insect, and so it feeds almost nothing. Doug Tallamy’s research at the University of Delaware found that a native oak supports well over 500 species of caterpillars in our region, while some of the most widely planted ornamental trees support fewer than five. Since more than 90 percent of our terrestrial birds raise their young on caterpillars, a yard full of the wrong trees is a yard without baby birds.
These five are the non-native trees we most often remove or see declining on Long Island sites, and the native trees Spadefoot plants in their place. Every replacement is adapted to our sandy soils, our salt air, and our storms, and every one of them will be covered in birds.
1. Bradford (Callery) pear
What it is: The white-flowering street tree that every builder planted in front of every split-level from 1975 to 2005, and the one that smells like rotting fish for two weeks in April. Bradford pear (Pyrus calleryana) is native to China and Vietnam.
Why it fails: Its branches all leave the trunk at the same tight angle, so the tree splits in half in a wet snow or a thunderstorm, usually at about 20 years of age. Its leaves feed almost no native insects. And the cultivars have cross-pollinated into a thorny, fertile wild form that is now choking abandoned fields and roadsides across the Island; it is banned from sale in Ohio and Pennsylvania and on the invasive lists of most Northeastern states.
Plant instead:
- Shadbush / serviceberry (Amelanchier canadensis, A. laevis). The same early white bloom, a month earlier, followed by blueberry-flavored fruit that catbirds and cedar waxwings strip in June, and orange-red fall color. Multi-stemmed, 15 to 25 feet, happy in sand.
- Flowering dogwood (Cornus florida). White or pink bracts in May, red fruit for migrating thrushes in fall. Give it morning sun and afternoon shade and good air movement to keep anthracnose at bay.
- Hawthorn (Crataegus crus-galli, C. viridis). White bloom, persistent red fruit into winter, and dense thorny structure that nesting birds love.
2. Norway maple
What it is: The big, dense, dark-green (or purple-leaved “Crimson King”) shade maple on half the older streets in Nassau County, planted by the thousands after Dutch elm disease took the elms. Acer platanoides is native to Europe. You can tell it from our red and sugar maples by snapping a leaf stem: Norway maple bleeds milky white sap.
Why it fails: It casts shade so deep and its surface roots are so greedy that nothing grows beneath it, not grass, not shrubs, not the understory a tree needs. Its seedlings come up by the hundreds and are now the dominant invader of Long Island’s remaining woodlands, out-competing native oak and maple regeneration. It is a regulated invasive species in New York State. On top of all that, it is short-lived for a maple and prone to girdling roots, so the 60-year-old specimens are now failing on schedule.
Plant instead:
- Red maple (Acer rubrum). Our most common native tree for a reason: fast, adaptable from swamp to sand, red flowers in March for the earliest bees, and dependable scarlet fall color. Hosts roughly 280 species of caterpillars.
- Black tupelo / black gum (Nyssa sylvatica). The finest fall color of any Long Island tree, glossy summer leaves, blue fruit that birds fight over, and a deep taproot that never lifts a sidewalk. Slow to start, worth the wait.
- White oak (Quercus alba) or scarlet oak (Q. coccinea). If you want a tree your grandchildren will sit under, plant an oak. Nothing else in the yard will feed more life.
3. Kousa dogwood
What it is: The dogwood the garden centers started pushing in the 1990s when our native dogwood was hit by anthracnose. Cornus kousa is from Japan, Korea, and China. It blooms in June, a month after the native, with pointed bracts and a bumpy, raspberry-looking fruit.
Why it fails: It is a handsome, disease-resistant tree that does almost nothing for Long Island. Its bloom comes after the spring pollinators need it, its leaves are nearly untouched by native caterpillars, and while people will tell you the birds eat the fruit, watch one in September: the fruit rots on the ground. It replaced a keystone native with an ornament. (Nurseries also sell Kousa-florida hybrids like the “Stellar” series, which share the problem.)
Plant instead:
- Flowering dogwood (Cornus florida), the real thing. Early May bracts, high-fat red fruit that fuels fall migration, and more than 100 species of caterpillars. Anthracnose is a problem mainly in deep shade with poor air flow; sited in dappled light with room around it, the native does fine, and resistant selections like ‘Appalachian Spring’ are available.
- Pagoda dogwood (Cornus alternifolia). Horizontal, tiered branching that gives it its name, creamy flat flower clusters in late spring, and blue-black fruit on red stems. Prefers part shade and a cool root zone.
- Eastern redbud (Cercis canadensis). Magenta flowers on bare branches in April, heart-shaped leaves, 20 to 25 feet. Native just to our south and west and thoroughly at home on the Island.
4. Crape myrtle
What it is: The pink, purple, or white summer-blooming tree with peeling cinnamon bark that has crept north from the Carolinas as our winters have warmed. Lagerstroemia indica is native to China and Southeast Asia. Twenty years ago it would not survive a Long Island winter; now it is in every big-box garden center from Hempstead to Riverhead.
Why it fails: Nothing here evolved with it. The flowers are showy but offer little to our bees, the leaves feed essentially no native caterpillars, and it is a magnet for the crape myrtle bark scale that has followed it north. It is also a signal of how we are gardening now: planting for the climate we are moving into rather than restoring what the climate we have is losing.
Plant instead:
- Sweetbay magnolia (Magnolia virginiana). A Long Island native of the South Shore swamps that tolerates ordinary garden soil. Lemon-scented white flowers through June and July, red seeds for birds in fall, silvery leaf backs that flash in the wind, and the host plant for the sweetbay silkmoth. The best summer-flowering small tree we have.
- Sourwood (Oxydendrum arboreum). Drooping sprays of white, lily-of-the-valley flowers in July, prized by bees, and crimson fall color. Native to the Appalachians and well suited to our acidic sand.
- American holly (Ilex opaca). If what you wanted from the crape myrtle was a small evergreen-looking anchor tree, plant this instead: a true Long Island native, red berries all winter, dense cover for birds. Plant a female and a male.
5. Leyland cypress (and the Japanese maple)
What it is: The fast-growing evergreen wall planted along property lines everywhere a pool went in. Leyland cypress (× Hesperotropsis leylandii) is a sterile hybrid of two West Coast conifers that was first noticed in a Welsh garden in 1888. It grows three feet a year, which is exactly why people buy it.
Why it fails: It grows three feet a year. Within 15 years the 6-foot hedge is a 50-foot wall of shallow-rooted, top-heavy trees that blow over onto the fence in a nor’easter, brown out from Seiridium canker and bagworm, and shade the neighbor’s yard. It is a biological desert: no native insect eats it, no bird nests in it by preference, and it drops nothing anyone can use. Its deciduous cousin on this list, the Japanese maple (Acer palmatum), is a lovely small specimen that shares the same problem: it is beautiful, and it feeds almost nothing.
Plant instead:
- Eastern red cedar (Juniperus virginiana). Our native evergreen screen. Dense, salt-tolerant, drought-proof once established, and the single most important winter food and shelter tree for birds on the Island; cedar waxwings are named for its berries. Choose narrow cultivars like ‘Emerald Sentinel’ for a hedge.
- American holly (Ilex opaca) and inkberry (Ilex glabra). Broadleaf evergreens for a layered screen that holds its structure in snow, with berries through winter.
- Atlantic white cedar (Chamaecyparis thyoides) for wet ground, a Long Island native nearly wiped out by logging and development, and a conservation priority worth planting back.
- For the Japanese maple’s spot: American hornbeam (Carpinus caroliniana), with its sinewy blue-gray trunk and orange fall color, or a small sassafras (Sassafras albidum) for mitten leaves, spicebush swallowtails, and the best orange on the Island in October.
How to make the switch
You do not have to cut down a healthy tree tomorrow. A mature Norway maple is still storing carbon and still shading the house, and the sudden loss of canopy is its own harm. The sensible plan is succession: plant the native replacement now, in the open light at the edge of the old tree’s canopy, and let it get established over three to five years. Then take the non-native down, chip it, and spread the chips under the new tree. For a Bradford pear or a Leyland hedge that is already splitting, skip the wait.
Two rules make the difference between a replacement that takes and one that sulks. Match the tree to the site, not the catalog: a sweetbay magnolia wants moisture, a scarlet oak wants dry sand, and both will tell you quickly if you got it wrong. And buy local ecotype stock when you can; a shadbush grown from Long Island seed is built for Long Island winters and Long Island soil. The Long Island Native Plant Initiative and the regional native nurseries can point you to it.
This is what Spadefoot does every week: removing invasive and non-native plantings and re-establishing the native plant communities that belong here, on everything from a quarter-acre lot to a town park. If you want help deciding what should come out and what should go in, start with a site visit. And if you missed them, the two earlier posts in this series cover the five ways we harm our yard trees and the five things we can do for them.